Buttercup Cottage Bakery, LLC
A small-batch sourdough bakery producing breads, bagels, and baked goods
What We Bake
An artisan sourdough bakery specializing in breads, bagels, and baked goods
Artisan Sourdough Loaves
Naturally leavened, long-fermented breads baked for flavor, structure, and consistency.
NY-Style Sourdough Bagels
Boiled and baked sourdough bagels with a crisp exterior and soft, chewy interior.
Pastries & Baked Goods
Dessert breads, cookies, brownies, and pastries made from scratch, with select rotating offerings.
Order Fresh Bakes
1. How to Order
Buttercup Cottage Bakery operates on a fresh-to-order system. All items are baked in small batches and prepared specifically for each order.
Orders are placed through our online ordering system where you can browse the current weeks menu, select your pickup location, and schedule your pickup date.
2. Ordering Timeline
Monday Menu Opens: Wednesday each week.
Saturday & Sunday Menu Opens: Sunday each week.
Monday pick up orders close Saturday at 6:00 PM each week.
Saturday & Sunday pickup orders close Wednesday at 6:00 PM each week.
3. Pickup Locations
Monday Pickup
Buttercup Cottage Bakery Pickup
Mosaic Life Care – SPA Desk
Moony's Coffee Shop
Saturday Pickup
Buttercup Cottage Bakery Pickup
Moony's Coffee Shop
Sunday Pickup
Buttercup Cottage Bakery Pickup
Choose your preferred pickup location during checkout.
What Customers Are Saying
Buttercup Cottage Bakery has grown thanks to the support of our community and the customers who come back week after week for fresh sourdough breads and small-batch baked goods!
Here are a few things our customers have shared.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“Amazing, truly! The sourdough cinnamon rolls are a must-try, and the dessert loaves are perfection. The blueberry muffins are a perfect start to the day!! Will definitely ordering more.😊”
— Brooklyn C. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“Her baked goods are delicious! I especially liked the New York style jalapeño cheddar sourdough bagels!”
— Megan C.⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“Delicious I will definitely purchase more. Sourdough rules... I'm a scone person and they are delicious. Sweet but not too sweet.”
— Kelly K.About Buttercup Cottage Bakery, LLC
Buttercup Cottage Bakery is a small-batch artisan bakery specializing in naturally fermented sourdough breads and handcrafted baked goods!
What began as a passion for traditional baking has grown into a beloved local bakery serving the St. Joseph community through weekly bake drops, pop-ups, and special events!
Every loaf, bagel, and pastry is made with the same care, quality ingredients, and slow fermentation that built the bakery from the beginning!
So glad you’re here!
With love & lots of flour,
