Welcome to Buttercup Cottage Bakery
Boujee Sourdough.
Sweet Treats.
Pretty Things.
Artisan sourdough, signature 5 oz cookies & beautifully handcrafted baked goods!
What We Bake
A LITTLE SOMETHING FOR EVERY CRAVING….
From artisan sourdough to over-the-top cookies and sweet treats, everything at Buttercup is handcrafted in small batches and made to be anything but ordinary.
SOURDOUGH
Bread, bagels, focaccia & more
SIGNATURE COOKIES
Our giant 5 oz cookie collection
SWEET TREATS
Scones, muffins, cinnamon rolls & more
The Weekly Bake Drop
Freshly baked. Small batch. Limited quantities.
01
SHOP THE DROP
Browse this week's rotating menu and choose your favorites.
02
CHOOSE YOUR PICKUP
Select your preferred pickup location during checkout.
03
PICK UP & ENJOY
We'll have everything freshly baked and ready for you.
THE SIGNATURE COOKIE COLLECTION
THE OG
Chocolate Chip
MEET THE ICONS
Meet Buttercup's signature 5 oz cookies — big, bold, handcrafted and anything but ordinary.
GOLDEN HOUR
Biscoff White Chip
COOKIE JAR CHAOS
Oreo M&M Chip
VELVET CRUSH
Red Velvet
💌 BUTTERCUP LOVE NOTES
SWEET WORDS FROM SWEET PEOPLE…
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“Amazing, truly! The sourdough cinnamon rolls are a must-try, and the dessert loaves are perfection. The blueberry muffins are a perfect start to the day!! Will definitely ordering more.😊”
— Brooklyn C. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“Her baked goods are delicious! I especially liked the New York style jalapeño cheddar sourdough bagels!”
— Megan C.⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“Delicious I will definitely purchase more. Sourdough rules... I'm a scone person and they are delicious. Sweet but not too sweet.”
— Kelly K.Meet the Baker Behind Buttercup
BEHIND THE BOWS & BREAD
Hi, I'm Morgan!
Buttercup Cottage Bakery started with a love for sourdough and grew into something sweeter than I ever imagined.
Every loaf, oversized cookie and sweet treat is handcrafted in small batches right here in St. Joseph, Missouri. Buttercup is all about taking the comfort of a neighborhood bakery and giving it a little extra personality — bold flavors, beautiful details and, of course, plenty of pink.
With love & lots of flour,
